In a high-stakes vice-presidential debate on October 1, 2024, U.S. Senator JD Vance and Minnesota Governor Tim Walz faced off in a crucial showdown with the upcoming election looming. The debate, hosted by CBS, saw the two candidates exchange views on major issues ranging from immigration to the Middle East crisis, taxes, abortion, and climate change. The candidates managed to keep the debate civil, starting and ending with a handshake, despite significant disagreements on policy.
Here are the key highlights from the Vance vs. Walz debate:
Vance Defends Trump’s 2020 Election Denial
JD Vance, Trump’s vice-presidential nominee, defended Trump’s role in the 2020 election protests, emphasizing that Trump had asked for peaceful demonstrations on January 6, 2021. Vance argued that the real threat to democracy is not Trump but the censorship of differing opinions, which he claims stifles free debate.
Walz, on the other hand, highlighted the danger Trump poses, pointing to his refusal to acknowledge his 2020 election defeat as undermining faith in the democratic process.
Immigration Clash: Moderators Cut the Mics
The debate’s most heated moment came when the topic of immigration was raised. Vance sidestepped a question about the economy and pivoted to his controversial statements about Haitian immigrants in Ohio. Walz interjected, leading to a chaotic back-and-forth, prompting CBS moderators to mute both candidates to restore order.
Unlike the previous debate between Trump and Harris, where mics were cut for extended periods, the interruptions were brief, allowing the debate to continue with a warning to both candidates.
Trump Targets Walz Over School Shooting Remarks: “Is He Insane?”
Donald Trump, never one to stay quiet, was live-tweeting throughout the debate. At one point, Trump responded to a comment by Walz about school shootings, where Walz mentioned becoming friends with some of the individuals involved. Trump took this statement out of context, calling Walz “insane” on his Truth Social account.
This remark attracted sharp criticism from Andrew Pollack, a parent of a Parkland shooting victim, who echoed Trump’s outrage and condemned Walz for his choice of words.
Vance Endorses Trump’s ‘Freedom Cities’
In an interesting twist, Vance endorsed one of Trump’s less-discussed proposals—the construction of 10 “Freedom Cities” on unused federal land. The idea, introduced early in Trump’s campaign, would see entirely new cities built from scratch. Walz criticized the concept, stating that federal lands are set aside for a reason, and such projects could harm the environment.
Guns and Borders: Vance Blames Mexico for U.S. Gun Culture
On the topic of gun violence, Vance shifted blame to Mexico, claiming that nearly 90% of guns used in crimes in the U.S. are trafficked by Mexican cartels. Walz quickly countered, pointing out that most of these guns are originally from the U.S., and it’s American gun culture, not foreign cartels, that drives the violence.
Walz also shared a personal story about his son Gus witnessing a shooting while playing volleyball at a community center, adding a human element to the debate.
Trump Denies Supporting a Federal Abortion Ban
Abortion, a key issue in the debate, saw Trump weigh in once again via social media. He emphatically denied supporting a federal abortion ban, stating it should be left to individual states to decide. Vance echoed Trump’s stance, walking back previous comments in which he appeared open to a nationwide ban.
Walz took the opportunity to share the harrowing story of Amanda Zurawski, a woman who was denied an abortion in Texas until she developed sepsis. Walz argued that restrictive abortion laws like those supported by Vance are dangerous to women’s health.
Walz’s Tiananmen Square Misstep
Walz faced questions about past misleading statements regarding the Tiananmen Square massacre, where he had previously claimed to have been in Hong Kong during the incident, which records later showed to be untrue. Walz admitted to “misspeaking” but emphasized his commitment to public service and the lessons he learned from China.
Trump Questions Walz’s Leadership, Labels Him ‘Tampon Tim’
As the debate drew to a close, Trump returned to his social media platform to label Walz “nervous” and “weird,” mocking his note-taking habits. The former president derisively called Walz “Tampon Tim” in reference to a controversial law Walz signed in Minnesota requiring tampon dispensers in boys’ restrooms. Vance, on the other hand, received praise from Trump, who called him a “warrior” and a “brilliant guy.”
Vance-Walz Divide on Middle East Crisis
The debate opened with a discussion on the Middle East, particularly regarding Israel and Iran. Vance criticized Walz’s running mate, Kamala Harris, for her handling of the Iran nuclear deal and suggested that Trump’s exit from the deal was in the best interest of U.S. national security. Walz disagreed, arguing that Trump’s policies only accelerated Iran’s path to a nuclear weapon.
Final Thoughts: A Civil Showdown
Despite the sharp policy divides, the debate concluded on a surprisingly cordial note, with both candidates exchanging friendly banter with their partners as the cameras rolled. However, the clear contrasts between Vance’s staunch support for Trump’s populist agenda and Walz’s focus on steady, experienced leadership ensured that voters will have plenty to ponder ahead of the election.
Must Read: Iran Missile Strike: Massive Crater Near Mossad HQ, Israel Vows Retaliation
